Critical thinking · Everyday claims

A post says coffee drinkers live longer

17 thoughts, 4 chains. Every chain starts with the same thought and follows one line of questions to where it ends. Start with the first, then scroll sideways for the others.

  1. Start here

    A post says that people who drink coffee live longer.
    How do you know?
    The post links to a study of half a million adults.
    Really?
    The study compared people who already drank coffee with people who did not.
    So what?
    Comparing two groups shows a link, not a cause.
    Alternatives?
    People who drink coffee may be healthier in other ways.
    Be specific!
    Sick people often give up coffee.
    So what?
    A group of coffee drinkers has fewer sick people from the start.
  2. Chain 2

    A post says that people who drink coffee live longer.
    Who do you trust?
    The post comes from a company that sells coffee.
    So what?
    The company gains when I believe the post.
    So what?
    A source that gains from my belief needs a second source.
  3. Chain 3

    A post says that people who drink coffee live longer.
    Assumptions?
    I assume the headline matches what the study found.
    How can you find out?
    I can read the summary of the study instead of the post.
    Then what?
    The summary of the study calls the link modest.
    So what?
    The headline made a small finding sound like a big promise.
  4. Chain 4

    A post says that people who drink coffee live longer.
    Then what?
    I am about to share the post with my family.
    Why?
    The post tells me what I want to hear.
    So (Decide)
    I share the summary of the study instead of the headline.

Thinking tools in this session: How do you know? Who do you trust? Assumptions? Then what? Really? So what? Alternatives? Be specific! How can you find out? Why? So (Decide)