Critical thinking · Everyday claims
A post says coffee drinkers live longer
17 thoughts, 4 chains. Every chain starts with the same thought and follows one line of questions to where it ends. Start with the first, then scroll sideways for the others.
Start here
A post says that people who drink coffee live longer.How do you know?The post links to a study of half a million adults.Really?The study compared people who already drank coffee with people who did not.So what?Comparing two groups shows a link, not a cause.Alternatives?People who drink coffee may be healthier in other ways.Be specific!Sick people often give up coffee.So what?A group of coffee drinkers has fewer sick people from the start.Chain 2
A post says that people who drink coffee live longer.Who do you trust?The post comes from a company that sells coffee.So what?The company gains when I believe the post.So what?A source that gains from my belief needs a second source.Chain 3
A post says that people who drink coffee live longer.Assumptions?I assume the headline matches what the study found.How can you find out?I can read the summary of the study instead of the post.Then what?The summary of the study calls the link modest.So what?The headline made a small finding sound like a big promise.Chain 4
A post says that people who drink coffee live longer.Then what?I am about to share the post with my family.Why?The post tells me what I want to hear.So (Decide)I share the summary of the study instead of the headline.
Thinking tools in this session: How do you know? Who do you trust? Assumptions? Then what? Really? So what? Alternatives? Be specific! How can you find out? Why? So (Decide)